This decadent vegan Oreo pie is made with an Oreo cookie crust, creamy chocolate peanut butter center and a whipped coconut cream topping.
So I’ve gone ahead and made the most decadent pie I could dream of.
Well, another one at least, since I have been known to make decadent pies before.
I was scrolling facebook, as you do. And a recipe video starting playing.
It was a pie recipe quite different to this one, in the sense that it used a heap of ingredients that did not come anywhere near this pie, like cream cheese and heavy cream, but it gave me the idea for this delicious vegan Oreo pie.
And like pretty much all of my recipes, I had to test it a couple of times before I perfected it, so Jaye has been eating this pie every day for a couple of weeks, and there have been NO complaints from him.
How To Make Vegan Oreo Pie
You will find full instructions and measurements in the recipe card at the bottom of the post. This is a summary of the process to go along with the process photos.
The Oreo crust is just two ingredients, so that’s super easy. And the coconut whipped cream topping is a breeze to make.
It was the chocolate peanut butter mousse center that I had a little trouble with.
I wanted it to be very mousse-like, and the first time I tried it, it started OFF very mousse-like but then firmed up in the fridge to be mousse-like no longer – basically, it was too firm.
I had briefly considered using tofu for this, but quickly discarded that idea. So far I have resisted tofu additions to desserts. But as with other things I once resisted but ended up being awesome (like vegan chocolate avocado mousse), I’ll probably change my mind on this sometime.
The winning formula for the chocolate peanut butter mousse center turned out to be creating the mix to be VERY liquid. And then it firms up in the fridge to the exact mousse consistency.
So when you make this pie, don’t freak out when you’re pouring the mousse layer on and it’s so liquid you can’t imagine how this will turn into mousse – never fear!
Provided you’ve followed the recipe – it firms up perfectly into the most delish peanut butter mousse ever.
Top with the whipped coconut cream, some vegan chocolate sprinkles and crushed peanuts and you have a dessert to write home about.
Each layer offsets every other layer beautifully. The coconut whipped cream topping is left plain (no added sugar or flavorings) so that it offsets the sweetness of the first two layers. You have the crunchy Oreo cookie base, the light and dreamy chocolate peanut butter mousse center, and the whipped cream topping which rounds it off perfectly.
Storing and Freezing
You have to keep this refrigerated. Cover and keep it in the fridge and consume within around 5 days for the best tastiest results. We did have a pie in the fridge for 7 days once and it was still fine, but for the best taste results, try to consume within 5 days.
Once out the fridge it will melt fairly soon. Jaye tried to take a slice to work one day, but by the time he got there it had melted completely, and we’re in what passes for winter in this part of the world, so it’s not super hot (okay it’s still pretty hot here).
So keep it in the fridge, and serve it straight out of the fridge. It’s not one you’ll take to work unless you’re taking a cooler bag or it’s actually cold where you are.
I haven’t tried freezing this one but my feeling is that it likely wouldn’t work that great for freezing. I think the coconut cream topping might separate or get weird once it thaws out.
More Delicious Vegan Pie Recipes
- Vegan Chocolate Pie
- Vegan Pumpkin Pie
- Vegan Sweet Potato Pie
- Vegan Banoffee Pie
- Vegan Coconut Cream Pie
- Vegan Lemon Pie
Did you make this recipe? Be sure to leave a comment and rating below!
Vegan Oreo Pie
Ingredients
Oreo Cookie Crust:
- 24 Oreo Cookies
- ¼ cup Melted Vegan Butter (56g)
Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse Center:
- ½ cup Smooth salted Peanut Butter (125g)
- 1 cup Canned Coconut Cream (240ml) Unsweetened
- ¼ cup Cocoa Powder (21g) Unsweetened
- 1 cup Powdered Sugar (120g)
Topping:
- 1 ¼ cups Canned Coconut Cream (300ml) hardened cream only from one 14-ounce can, chilled overnight in the fridge
- Crushed Peanuts
- Vegan Chocolate Sprinkles
Instructions
- Place the Oreos into the food processor and process into a fine crumble.
- Melt the vegan butter and pour over the crushed Oreos and mix in properly.
- Pat firmly down into a pie dish and place into the freezer to set.
- Now add the peanut butter, coconut cream, cocoa powder and powdered sugar into the bowl of your stand mixer and beat together until perfectly smooth.
- Pour this out over the Oreo cookie base and place into the refrigerator to set.
- Once the peanut butter chocolate mousse layer has set to firm, prepare your topping. Remove your chilled can of coconut cream from the fridge, and spoon out only the cream section which will have risen to the top. Throw out the watery section that remains.
- Add this to the bowl of your stand mixer and whip it up until it has reached whipped cream consistency.
- Smooth down the whipped cream topping on top of the chocolate peanut butter mousse center.
- Top with crushed peanuts and vegan chocolate sprinkles and serve.
Notes
- If you’d like to use a store-bought vegan whipped cream topping then you can definitely do so.
- Keep leftover pie stored in the refrigerator and consume within 5 days for best results.
The coconut cream that needs to be refrigerated, can I open the can pour it in a mixing bowl, cover it and refrigerate it overnight? I’m thinking it would be easier to separate and it would be colder in the bowl.
Hi Gail, I haven’t ever done that so I’m not sure! My worry is that it might not separate if it’s out of the can.
I couldn’t get my coconut cream to work sadly. Will try another brand next time. But really does taste amazing even without it. Served it with vegan vanilla ice cream instead.
So glad it was tasty anyway. 🙂
Hi Alison,
this pie looks delicious! I am planning on making it, just had one question about the coconut cream in the chocolate layer: do you use the coconut cream from the can you put it in the fridge or another one? (which has not been cooled).
Thank you!!
Hi Lisa! The coconut cream in the filling is just straight from the can, not chilled first. Whereas the whipped cream topping is from a can of chilled coconut cream that is then whipped. Hope that clarifies! 🙂
I don’t suppose I can make this coconut free? Sadly, I’m intolerant to coconut 🙁
Hi Susan! You could try using a ready made soy cream instead. Though I have not tested it myself.
OMG!
🙂